Home › Blog › What Is the Best Comic Book Value Guide?
What Is the Best Comic Book Value Guide?
The short answer
The best comic book value guide depends on the book. For slabs, GPAnalysis and GoCollect beat any printed guide because they track real sales by grade. For raw books, use eBay sold listings and grade conservatively.
Overstreet is still the reference for Golden and Silver Age raw baselines, but it isn’t where today’s slab prices get set.
Which comic book value guide should you use?
Pick by the book in your hand. GPAnalysis and GoCollect suit slabs, while Heritage’s archive is free for scarce books.
| Source | Best for | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| GPAnalysis (GPA) | CGC slabs, with more than 7.6 million logged sales from over 40 venues | $10.95 a month or $119 a year |
| GoCollect | Fair market value by grade | Free tier, or $9 a month for Pro |
| CovrPrice | Raw and modern books | Check its site |
| eBay sold listings | A quick check on almost anything | Free |
| Heritage archive | Scarce books | Free |
| Overstreet #55 | Golden and Silver Age raw baselines | $34.95 softcover, $44.95 hardcover |
Overstreet #55 reached shops on February 25, 2026, after long delays. That’s the latest edition we could confirm, so check the date on any copy you’re relying on.
Got a stack and don’t know where to begin? The free workbook covers what a book is worth, where to look it up and which red flags to check.
Get the free Comic Buyer’s Playbook: a PDF with 12 checks to run before you pay, restoration red flags, and 8 copy-paste AI prompts.
Is the Overstreet price guide still accurate?
As a reference, yes. Published since 1970, it still earns respect from dealers on older raw books, but slab prices move faster than an annual book can, so that market now runs on GPA and GoCollect.
Overstreet tells you where a raw Golden or Silver Age book sits. Sold data decides what to pay or accept.
Why does grade change the value so much?
Because the top grades carry most of the price on modern keys. The 2026 Guide’s Grader Comparison Chart measured sold prices over roughly 14 months to September 3, 2026. With a CGC 9.8 set at 100%, a 9.6 sold for:
Amazing Spider-Man #300: 34%
New Mutants #98: 47%
Spawn #1: 56%
So look up your book’s grade, not its best-looking comp. A raw book priced off a 9.8 sale is priced wrong, and “NM” on a raw listing is only the seller’s opinion.
What will a dealer pay compared with the guide?
Selling raw, the 2026 Guide says to expect roughly 40–70% of value. It puts local shops around 40–50% of fair market value on bulk, and closer to full value on an individually valuable key.
Much of that gap comes from grading. By the guide’s account, a dealer typically prices a raw book about four tenths of a grade below whatever you call it.
Common books are a different story. MyComicShop says it sells most comics from the 1980s onward for $1–$3 and buys them “for less than $1.00 or not at all.”
Is the 2026 Guide a comic price guide?
No, so don’t buy it looking for a list of book values. Use the sources above to look up a comic.
Buying and Selling Comics: The 2026 Guide covers what comes after the lookup: how to read those numbers, when grading pays, what shops pay and where to sell. If you’re not ready to sell yet, start with the free Comic Buyer’s Playbook.
Questions people also ask
What is the best site to check comic book values?
For slabbed books, GPAnalysis and GoCollect track sold prices by grade. For raw books, eBay sold listings are the best free check, and Heritage’s archive covers scarce books.
Is Overstreet still the comic book price guide to use?
For Golden and Silver Age raw baselines, yes. For current slab prices, the market has moved to GPAnalysis and GoCollect, which track actual sales by grade.
Is there a free comic book value guide?
eBay sold listings and Heritage’s archive at comics.ha.com are free, and GoCollect has a useful free tier. Together they’ll price most books.
How much will a comic shop pay compared with guide value?
The 2026 Guide puts local shops at 40–50% of fair market value on bulk, and closer to full value on an individually valuable key. Common books from the 1980s onward often bring less than $1 each.
Keep reading
- Heritage Auctions comics archive
- Overstreet: #55 on-sale date, February 25, 2026
- Overstreet #55 softcover price
- Overstreet #55 hardcover price
- MyComicShop: Sell your comics
- GPAnalysis: sales tracked
- GPAnalysis: subscription prices
- GoCollect: pricing
- CovrPrice
- Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide history (first published 1970)
- Grade percentages and dealer offers: the 2026 Guide’s Grader Comparison Chart (130point.com sales, about 14 months to 3 September 2026) and Dealer Buy-Rate Sheet